I’ve sat in enough rooms with CEOs facing a big decision to notice a pattern. Vistage members bring recurring issues to meetings or business owners refuse to make difficult commitments. The issue processing, pro/cons list, and financial model look like analysis. But mostly they are the intellect trying to predict how a future outcome will feel.
Joe Hudson from the Art of Accomplishment podcast puts words to it. Decision-making, he says, is always an emotional problem first. To make the best decisions (or solve the most important issues), we should lean into our emotions and our core principles.
The neuroscience backs this up. Your brain keeps a record of how past outcomes felt in the body (the racing heart, the knot in the stomach). When a choice shows up, it replays those signals and tags each option as good or bad before you start to reason.
Scientists discovered this from patients with damage to the part of the brain that does this emotional tagging (the ventromedial prefrontal cortex). Even when their intelligence and logic center were intact, decision-making fell apart. They would analyze options at length and still fail to choose, even for simple choices like what to eat.
Feeling is how the brain weighs options. Without it, logic has nothing to decide with.
That is why more analysis doesn’t unstick a stuck decision. Instead, fear is the bottleneck. Fear shrinks the choice to binary options, and neither is the one you want.
The feeling you avoid is often the one that unlocks the decision. Fear is the loudest, but not the only one emotion strangling decisions. Anger, grief, and shame sit under the hardest calls, too. And resentment can build each time we trade our principles to ease our own or someone else’s emotional discomfort.
Leaders who run on unexamined emotions pay twice. They burn out, and they build a company designed to protect how they feel instead of one they want to lead.
The emotional decision comes first, then logic follows. You don’t need another framework. You need these three moves.
1 – Name the feeling before naming options
When a choice that should be simple turns heavy, something underneath is driving. Watch for the tells: reworking the model one more time, polling one more advisor, asking for more data.
When you see a tell, ask what is under it. Fear? Anger? Grief? Anxiety? Shame?
A feeling you can name is a feeling you can choose around. A feeling you can’t name is deciding for you.
Take the CEO who knows a long-time executive has been outgrown by the role. She orders another performance review, drafts another 90-day plan, and asks one more board member for a view. None of it is analysis. Underneath sits sadness at losing someone who helped build the company, and shame at letting it run this long. Once she names both, the decision becomes clear, and the tough conversation is kinder.
2 – Walk past the false end
Negative emotions tell a story that stops at the worst moment. ‘If we lose this, we’re finished,’ is a false end.
Keep walking. Picture the worst case in detail, then the day after, then the month and years after. What is reality? What happens next? What’s possible?
Once you are willing to live through that story, it loses its grip and options open beyond either/or. We make space for ‘Response-Ability.’ The questions change from ‘should we or shouldn’t we?’ to ‘what is mine to control?’, ‘what do I own that can make us stronger?’ and ‘what could go right?’
3 – Let a principle decide
A principle is a decision you make in advance when you are calm, or a predefined behavior for certain circumstances.
You don’t need a values retreat to find yours. Look back at last year or farther for the moments you enjoyed most, the low points, the calls you’re proud of and the ones you regret. A few short rules will come out of that reflection, and they will settle most of what lands on your desk.
A good decision is one where you stayed true to these principles. They don’t make everyone comfortable or spare your own ego. They help you feel good about the decision regardless of the outcome.
One of my principles is ‘adventure.’ To me it means life is a journey with goals, but no ultimate destination. It settles many decisions and drives healthy behaviors. When a choice comes down to the safe path or the one with more to learn, adventure picks the second – it’s why I started with Vistage a few years ago. When the going gets tough, it reminds me I signed up for courage to start and grit to stay the course. And when an option would cost my health or my joy, it says no, because I need both for the journey.
Putting it together under pressure
Hudson tells the story of a CEO who was deep into the sale of his company when the buyer started to wobble. The board saw two options: chase the buyer with a discount and concessions, or watch the deal die.
He did the inside work first. He named the fear in the room, ‘if we lose this buyer, we’re finished.’ He recognized it as a false end and walked through the deal dying: the hard board meeting, the hit to his pride, the work of building on as an independent company. He found he could live with it.
So he asked a different question. How could staying independent make this business stronger?
One of his principles answered it: Build a company to make the biggest impact. That didn’t require a sale.
He never chased. He told the board and the buyer where he stood and went back to building.
A year later the same buyer came back and paid a higher price.
It’s no surprise. Chasing from fear signals need, and need lowers the price. Holding to a principle signals strength, and strength pays a premium.
The steps also work in personal decisions. Hudson applied the steps as he and his wife grew and changed in his marriage of 27 years. He caught himself thinking, ‘I need to abandon my principles or I’ll lose her.’ So the two of them practiced mourning their marriage: they imagined it had ended, and what happened after they separated. Once they felt and assessed the loss clearly, the fear loosened. They then expanded options and chose how to be together without compromising their principles.
What decisions have been circling for you this week? Are you missing information, or are you avoiding a feeling?
The leaders who decide best and fastest accept what they will feel, and they know what they won’t trade. That brings more cheer to deciding (more on Cheer to come).
I’m working with a local company to uncover their principles. Which do you use to help make tough calls, and how did you find them?